We love it when we find weird and unique indie games to tell you all about! Our alien friends to the left herald these occasions.
sylvie’s Games Don’t Have To Be Good To Be Good is an interesting little browser game where the point is figuring out how to play, then what to do. It’s really short! You can probably finish it in five minutes.
The description calls it a manifesto, and I can see that, and also agree with it. (And it’s an entry in Manifestø Jam 2026 too.) My belief about game worth is that there can be a hundred things wrong with a game, and everyone can agree that they’re wrong, but if there’s one really really good thing about it, just one powerful elemental spark of awesome, if it’s strong enough, it can make all the “wrong” things meaningless.
It’s points to one of the great problems with game journalism as it’s currently practiced. The traditional lists of flaws, the reporting of how “smooth” it is, of how realistic the polygons are and the other excuses a reviewer gives not to play something, none of those things matter. Not if the game has something really good going for it, and to obsess over trivialities will blind you to many worthwhile things.
It’s why it took forever to get the gaming press to notice roguelikes! The genre of classic roguelikes feels like it was designed to be a koan, a seemingly-impossible question that prompts thought, meditation and eventually enlightenment. Classic roguelikes (or as I’m coming to call them, true roguelikes) look entirely unlike everything magazines and websites told players they were supposed like. They rejected everything that being good meant. So why are they fun? Please contemplate that with me now. Ooommmm….
Coming back to Games Don’t Have To etc., it does push the boundaries of enjoyability a bit, but overcoming its purposeful vagueness turns out to be a puzzle to solve. And you can do it! Please give it a try. It might not be an all-time classic, but it’s an enjoyable use of five minutes. See if you agree.
Games Don’t Have To Be Good To Be Good, by sylvie (itch.io, web, $0)
